Negative Octafinals vs. Wayzata (Disease Surveillance)
1NC:
1. Topicality -- gov't-to-gov't
2. Politics -- LOST good, political capital link, ocean health and economy impacts
3. Diplomatic Capital -- Egypt/Israel, Egyptian first strike impact
4. Fiscal Discipline -- Schiller/confidence internal
5. AU CP -- AU do disease surveillance and request help from the CDC
6. Bioterrorism Defense
7. Bird Flu Defense
Negative Round 6 vs. Groves
Aspec
LOS good
Dip cap-Egypt scenario
Dip Cap DA
As part of its attempt to maintain peace process momentum, US is engaging Israel to halt settlements in Har Homa. Lack of a concession will poison Israeli relations with Egypt Daily Star Dec. 27, 07 ["Abbas to seek Rice's help in halting settlements," Daily Star, Thursday, December 27, 2007, pg. http://www.dailystar.com.lb /article.asp?edition_id=10 &categ_id=2&article_id=87659 ]
Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas will demand--> more to stop weapons smuggling into Gaza.
The plan will hinder Rice ability to garner Israeli concessions Anderson & Grewell 01 - Senior fellow @ Hoover Institution & Research associate @ Political Economy Research Center [Terry L. Anderson and J. Bishop Grewell, "It Isn't Easy Being Green: Environmental Policy Implications for Foreign Policy, International Law, and Sovereignty," Chicago Journal of International Law, Fall 2001, 2 Chi. J. Int'l L. 427] Foreign policy is a bag of goods--> ensuring access to foreign economies." n40 Har homa settlement will torpedo Israeli-Palestinian negotiations Al Jazeera Dec. 27, 07 ["Israeli building plan clouds talks," THURSDAY, DECEMBER 27, 2007 7:49 MECCA TIME, 4:49 GMT, pg. http://english.aljazeera.net /NR/exeres/8F62C3EC-589D-49C6 -B014-59D724086093.htm ]
An Israeli building programme planned for East Jerusalem --> Palestinian land in east Jerusalem.
The collapse of the peace process causes nuclear war
There has been a kind of conspiracy of silence over the potential consequences of a breakdown of the peace process
Offsets CP (take resources from land troops and give to airforce)
Heg bad
Heidegger K
2NR: Heidegger K
Negative Round 2 vs. KCC
Chattahoochee Neg
Round # 2
Vs Team: KCC
Judge: Jason Sykes
Case Args:
Narrative prevent change, 87
Justify scapegoating and genocide
Warran 87
Narratives foundation of Hitler’s regimes
Use of narratives is justification for stereotypes
Narratives can’t solve only given to 5 people
Aff’s attempt to speak out prevents us from solving oppression
Alcoff, 92
Off Case Args:
Extra topical voter
Explodes aff ground
Doesn’t justify resolution
Vote neg on presumption
T doesn’t have usfg adopt a policy
Grammar and writing 5
Resoved is reflexive
Merriam Webster 96
1. Ground will always win merits of framework
2. Policy debate is between policymakers allows for us to create peace
rawls, 99
1. objectivity- leads to biased b/c judges already know
Heg DA
Assistance is the lynchpin of all soft power policies
That increase heg nye, 4
intervention and power wars
Cap K
Franke
Counter-culture is fundamental barrier
Radical resistance provides system with necessary capital
Zizek, 3
Capitalism causes extinction
Marko, 3
Commodification prevents change
Franke, 97
Capitalist commodification = A bomb
Alt is to reject capitalism we hace to embrace utopian world w/o cap
Block Strategy:
Case,
Narratives sound good which causes people to trust them. The way they use narratives is biased. Speaking for others is bad make them defend it its bad.
Only 5 people in this round
Even if they change stuff we’ll think it was a bad-decision.
K
O/w
1. Value to life
2. Turns 1AC impacts causes oppression. Causes racism
Commodification. Become t-shirts and bracelets don't actually care
Maintains the same kind of debate franke
framework
2nr Strategy:
Cap, Speaking for others turns, narratives bad, framework (we’re ok not you = bad)
Team Name Neg Hootch
Round # 6
Vs Team: Groves
Judge: Jon Sharp
Case Args:
Terrorists won’t attack America
Terrorists don’t have nukes
Terrorists won’t get nukes
quarantines prevent epidemics
diseases are short-term
virus won’t cause extinction
Hege Bad
War
Terror
Disease
Prolif
China War
Russia War
Off Case Args:
ASPEC
Heidegger
LOST Good
A. Lost passes
Ian Williams 12-10-07 “Anarchy on the High Seas”
“When bullets are to be bitten, never let it be....ratified since Ronald Reagan.”
B. Bush’s pol cap is key
Will Reisinger 12-26-07
“The LOST debate”
“There is an intense political and legal debate goin...party already struggling to stay afloat”
C. Spending $ on aid to Africa will cost pol cap
NYT 9-18-05
“God knows Africa could use a song or two...weak governance, self-defeating economic policies.”
D. LOST key to War on Terror, Econ, and Oceans
Spencer P. Boyer 10-29-07, “Why the Senate should ratify the Law of the Sea Convention”
“The Law of the Sea Convention is one....compete with foreign companies for marine resources.”
E. Sid Ahmed
F. Loss of oceans cause extinction
Oceans at risk 05
“Oceans provide 95 percent of the living space....web of life for future generations.”
G. Bearden
Diplomatic Capital- Israel/Egypt
Block Strategy:
Heidegger
Dip Cap
Hege Bad
Terrorism and Disease mitigation
2nr Strategy:
Heidegger Neg Vs. Groves round 6
Aspec
LOS good
Dip cap-Egypt scenario
Offsets CP (take resources from land troops and give to airforce)
Heg bad
Heidegger K
2NR: Heidegger K
Chattahoochee Neg
Round # 2
Vs Team: KCC
Judge: Jason Sykes
Case Args:
Narrative prevent change, 87
Justify scapegoating and genocide
Warran 87
Narratives foundation of Hitler’s regimes
Use of narratives is justification for stereotypes
Narratives can’t solve only given to 5 people
Aff’s attempt to speak out prevents us from solving oppression
Alcoff, 92
Off Case Args:
Extra topical voter
Explodes aff ground
Doesn’t justify resolution
Vote neg on presumption
T doesn’t have usfg adopt a policy
Grammar and writing 5
Resoved is reflexive
Merriam Webster 96
1. Ground will always win merits of framework
2. Policy debate is between policymakers allows for us to create peace
rawls, 99
1. objectivity- leads to biased b/c judges already know
Heg DA
Assistance is the lynchpin of all soft power policies
That increase heg nye, 4
intervention and power wars
Cap K
Franke
Counter-culture is fundamental barrier
Radical resistance provides system with necessary capital
Zizek, 3
Capitalism causes extinction
Marko, 3
Commodification prevents change
Franke, 97
Capitalist commodification = A bomb
Alt is to reject capitalism we hace to embrace utopian world w/o cap
Block Strategy:
Case,
Narratives sound good which causes people to trust them. The way they use narratives is biased. Speaking for others is bad make them defend it its bad.
Only 5 people in this round
Even if they change stuff we’ll think it was a bad-decision.
K
O/w
1. Value to life
2. Turns 1AC impacts causes oppression. Causes racism
Commodification. Become t-shirts and bracelets don't actually care
Maintains the same kind of debate franke
framework
2nr Strategy:
Cap, Speaking for others turns, narratives bad, framework (we’re ok not you = bad)
Negative Octafinals vs. Wayzata (Disease Surveillance)
1NC:
1. Topicality -- gov't-to-gov't
2. Politics -- LOST good, political capital link, ocean health and economy impacts
3. Diplomatic Capital -- Egypt/Israel, Egyptian first strike impact
4. Fiscal Discipline -- Schiller/confidence internal
5. AU CP -- AU do disease surveillance and request help from the CDC
6. Bioterrorism Defense
7. Bird Flu Defense
Negative Round 6 vs. Groves
Aspec
LOS good
Dip cap-Egypt scenario
Dip Cap DA
As part of its attempt to maintain peace process momentum, US is engaging Israel to halt settlements in Har Homa. Lack of a concession will poison Israeli relations with Egypt
Daily Star Dec. 27, 07 ["Abbas to seek Rice's help in halting settlements," Daily Star, Thursday, December 27, 2007, pg. http://www.dailystar.com.lb /article.asp?edition_id=10 &categ_id=2&article_id=87659 ]
Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas will demand --> more to stop weapons smuggling into Gaza.
The plan will hinder Rice ability to garner Israeli concessions
Anderson & Grewell 01 - Senior fellow @ Hoover Institution & Research associate @ Political Economy Research Center [Terry L. Anderson and J. Bishop Grewell, "It Isn't Easy Being Green: Environmental Policy Implications for Foreign Policy, International Law, and Sovereignty," Chicago Journal of International Law, Fall 2001, 2 Chi. J. Int'l L. 427]
Foreign policy is a bag of goods --> ensuring access to foreign economies." n40
Har homa settlement will torpedo Israeli-Palestinian negotiations
Al Jazeera Dec. 27, 07 ["Israeli building plan clouds talks," THURSDAY, DECEMBER 27, 2007 7:49 MECCA TIME, 4:49 GMT, pg. http://english.aljazeera.net /NR/exeres/8F62C3EC-589D-49C6 -B014-59D724086093.htm ]
An Israeli building programme planned for East Jerusalem --> Palestinian land in east Jerusalem.
The collapse of the peace process causes nuclear war
SLATER '99
Jerome Slater, professor of political science at SUNY at Buffalo, March/April 19 99, Tikkun Magazine, http://www.tikkun.org/magazine /index.cfm/action/tikkun/issue /tik9903/article/990312a.htmlThere has been a kind of conspiracy of silence over the potential consequences of a breakdown of the peace process
Offsets CP (take resources from land troops and give to airforce)
Heg bad
Heidegger K
2NR: Heidegger K
Negative Round 2 vs. KCC
Chattahoochee NegRound # 2
Vs Team: KCC
Judge: Jason Sykes
Case Args:
Narrative prevent change, 87
Justify scapegoating and genocide
Warran 87
Narratives foundation of Hitler’s regimes
Use of narratives is justification for stereotypes
Narratives can’t solve only given to 5 people
Aff’s attempt to speak out prevents us from solving oppression
Alcoff, 92
Off Case Args:
Extra topical voter
Explodes aff ground
Doesn’t justify resolution
Vote neg on presumption
T doesn’t have usfg adopt a policy
Grammar and writing 5
Resoved is reflexive
Merriam Webster 96
1. Ground will always win merits of framework
2. Policy debate is between policymakers allows for us to create peace
rawls, 99
1. objectivity- leads to biased b/c judges already know
Heg DA
Assistance is the lynchpin of all soft power policies
That increase heg nye, 4
intervention and power wars
Cap K
Franke
Counter-culture is fundamental barrier
Radical resistance provides system with necessary capital
Zizek, 3
Capitalism causes extinction
Marko, 3
Commodification prevents change
Franke, 97
Capitalist commodification = A bomb
Alt is to reject capitalism we hace to embrace utopian world w/o cap
Block Strategy:
Case,
Narratives sound good which causes people to trust them. The way they use narratives is biased. Speaking for others is bad make them defend it its bad.
Only 5 people in this round
Even if they change stuff we’ll think it was a bad-decision.
K
O/w
1. Value to life
2. Turns 1AC impacts causes oppression. Causes racism
Commodification. Become t-shirts and bracelets don't actually care
Maintains the same kind of debate franke
framework
2nr Strategy:
Cap, Speaking for others turns, narratives bad, framework (we’re ok not you = bad)
Team Name Neg Hootch
Round # 6
Vs Team: Groves
Judge: Jon Sharp
Case Args:
Terrorists won’t attack America
Terrorists don’t have nukes
Terrorists won’t get nukes
quarantines prevent epidemics
diseases are short-term
virus won’t cause extinction
Hege Bad
War
Terror
Disease
Prolif
China War
Russia War
Off Case Args:
ASPEC
Heidegger
LOST Good
A. Lost passes
Ian Williams 12-10-07 “Anarchy on the High Seas”
“When bullets are to be bitten, never let it be....ratified since Ronald Reagan.”
B. Bush’s pol cap is key
Will Reisinger 12-26-07
“The LOST debate”
“There is an intense political and legal debate goin...party already struggling to stay afloat”
C. Spending $ on aid to Africa will cost pol cap
NYT 9-18-05
“God knows Africa could use a song or two...weak governance, self-defeating economic policies.”
D. LOST key to War on Terror, Econ, and Oceans
Spencer P. Boyer 10-29-07, “Why the Senate should ratify the Law of the Sea Convention”
“The Law of the Sea Convention is one....compete with foreign companies for marine resources.”
E. Sid Ahmed
F. Loss of oceans cause extinction
Oceans at risk 05
“Oceans provide 95 percent of the living space....web of life for future generations.”
G. Bearden
Diplomatic Capital- Israel/Egypt
Block Strategy:
Heidegger
Dip Cap
Hege Bad
Terrorism and Disease mitigation
2nr Strategy:
Heidegger Neg Vs. Groves round 6
Aspec
LOS good
Dip cap-Egypt scenario
Offsets CP (take resources from land troops and give to airforce)
Heg bad
Heidegger K
2NR: Heidegger K
Chattahoochee Neg
Round # 2
Vs Team: KCC
Judge: Jason Sykes
Case Args:
Narrative prevent change, 87
Justify scapegoating and genocide
Warran 87
Narratives foundation of Hitler’s regimes
Use of narratives is justification for stereotypes
Narratives can’t solve only given to 5 people
Aff’s attempt to speak out prevents us from solving oppression
Alcoff, 92
Off Case Args:
Extra topical voter
Explodes aff ground
Doesn’t justify resolution
Vote neg on presumption
T doesn’t have usfg adopt a policy
Grammar and writing 5
Resoved is reflexive
Merriam Webster 96
1. Ground will always win merits of framework
2. Policy debate is between policymakers allows for us to create peace
rawls, 99
1. objectivity- leads to biased b/c judges already know
Heg DA
Assistance is the lynchpin of all soft power policies
That increase heg nye, 4
intervention and power wars
Cap K
Franke
Counter-culture is fundamental barrier
Radical resistance provides system with necessary capital
Zizek, 3
Capitalism causes extinction
Marko, 3
Commodification prevents change
Franke, 97
Capitalist commodification = A bomb
Alt is to reject capitalism we hace to embrace utopian world w/o cap
Block Strategy:
Case,
Narratives sound good which causes people to trust them. The way they use narratives is biased. Speaking for others is bad make them defend it its bad.
Only 5 people in this round
Even if they change stuff we’ll think it was a bad-decision.
K
O/w
1. Value to life
2. Turns 1AC impacts causes oppression. Causes racism
Commodification. Become t-shirts and bracelets don't actually care
Maintains the same kind of debate franke
framework
2nr Strategy:
Cap, Speaking for others turns, narratives bad, framework (we’re ok not you = bad)