Plan Text – The usfg should substantially increase its grants for the prevention and treatment of communicable diseases to topically designated areas by unconditionally cancelling all bilateral debt owed to the US by those African nations We reserve the right to clarify.
1ac w/ cites
Adv 1 – Diseases
IMF loans require structural adjustment programs resulting in the destruction of Africa PH. Millions die
COlgan 2002
There is a hierarchy of grief and mourning that places Africans with disease at the bottom. Those in the lowest rungs are ungrievable and unmournable – denied their humanity! The impact is a discursive dehumanization that leads to violence and denies the value of the lives we don’t grieve ofr mourn for
Butler, prof rhetoric and comp lit at Berk; 2004; Precarious life: the powers and mourning oand violence ;32-35
A hierarchy of grief…unmakable and ungrieveable
The terminal impact to dehume is global nuclear apocalypse
Fashing 1993
Adv 2 – Global Civil Society
Bush’s response to 9/11 was a return to cold war models of inside-out, us-them and friend-enemy. Undermining international treaties and institutions, the achievements of global civil society, and marking a return to realism and national interest. Global civil society is needed more than ever.
Kaldor 2003
Public health and civil society are co-productive. Global civil society advances health rights, health care, patient rights, treatment access, resisting globalization and privatization, while building equity and social justice through strong public health systems, these successes and failure constitute global civil society.
South African Equity Network on Health et. Al; 2004
Global civil society is the alternative to war for five reasons
Kaldor 2003
Adv 3 – Solvency
Devt cancellation calls hhsould be inserted into our debates, decisions, and demands. Use it to analyze financial relations.
Keet 00
Debt cancellation would be a double vicotory for anti-debt social movements since the Bush admin has already stated its interest in removing the funds from structural adjustment programs in favor of grants. US action key
Ambrose 2005
US must lead the charge. Each US dollar is matched by eight from international community
Leach 99
Ghana Tanzania, and Zambia proves SSA nations would put repayments towards PH
JubileeUSA.org 2007
Contextual evidence proves we’re a grant and that’our grant is the assistance – prefer outr evidence b/c it about the OECD interpretation of grants
Yi 07
Framework –
Expert predictions about international affairas are rearely accurate and most often deterministic. Monkeys would be more accurate throwing darts at a board than experts making prophesies Mustiple steps in the’re DA’s make probabilityh low
Menand 2005
Reject DA framework of high magn and low prob
Suskind 2006
Das inev
Commondream.org 2007
Bush pushed multilateral and bilateral debt relief for Liberia DA’s emp. denied
Perino 2007
2ac Tricks, Add-Ons,
None
Answers To Off Case Args
T
WM
Debt cancellation is mandate
Cross apply 1ac stuff
^ proves we are pha
fiat Title Five is a mandate
Plan text makes it topical – plan earmarks – it is pha - comes down to who we define PHA
C-i –
Socio-economic stuff
Policy failure stuff bad
Socio-economic issues can’t be separated from policy
No case meets
Need reason why ours is special
No abuse
still have ground
CP
Perm – double solvency
Perm – US cancel debt and Japan give money
US doesn’t give money in plan anyways
U
Grapevine Aff
Round # 1
vs Team: Warner Robins
Judge: John Mann
Plan Text – The usfg should substantially increase its grants for the prevention and treatment of communicable diseases to topically designated areas by unconditionally cancelling all bilateral debt owed to the US by those African nations We reserve the right to clarify.
1ac w/ cites
Adv 1 – DiseasesIMF loans require structural adjustment programs resulting in the destruction of Africa PH. Millions die
COlgan 2002
There is a hierarchy of grief and mourning that places Africans with disease at the bottom. Those in the lowest rungs are ungrievable and unmournable – denied their humanity! The impact is a discursive dehumanization that leads to violence and denies the value of the lives we don’t grieve ofr mourn for
Butler, prof rhetoric and comp lit at Berk; 2004; Precarious life: the powers and mourning oand violence ;32-35
A hierarchy of grief…unmakable and ungrieveable
The terminal impact to dehume is global nuclear apocalypse
Fashing 1993
Adv 2 – Global Civil Society
Bush’s response to 9/11 was a return to cold war models of inside-out, us-them and friend-enemy. Undermining international treaties and institutions, the achievements of global civil society, and marking a return to realism and national interest. Global civil society is needed more than ever.
Kaldor 2003
Public health and civil society are co-productive. Global civil society advances health rights, health care, patient rights, treatment access, resisting globalization and privatization, while building equity and social justice through strong public health systems, these successes and failure constitute global civil society.
South African Equity Network on Health et. Al; 2004
Global civil society is the alternative to war for five reasons
Kaldor 2003
Adv 3 – Solvency
Devt cancellation calls hhsould be inserted into our debates, decisions, and demands. Use it to analyze financial relations.
Keet 00
Debt cancellation would be a double vicotory for anti-debt social movements since the Bush admin has already stated its interest in removing the funds from structural adjustment programs in favor of grants. US action key
Ambrose 2005
US must lead the charge. Each US dollar is matched by eight from international community
Leach 99
Ghana Tanzania, and Zambia proves SSA nations would put repayments towards PH
JubileeUSA.org 2007
Contextual evidence proves we’re a grant and that’our grant is the assistance – prefer outr evidence b/c it about the OECD interpretation of grants
Yi 07
Framework –
Expert predictions about international affairas are rearely accurate and most often deterministic. Monkeys would be more accurate throwing darts at a board than experts making prophesies Mustiple steps in the’re DA’s make probabilityh low
Menand 2005
Reject DA framework of high magn and low prob
Suskind 2006
Das inev
Commondream.org 2007
Bush pushed multilateral and bilateral debt relief for Liberia DA’s emp. denied
Perino 2007
2ac Tricks, Add-Ons,
NoneAnswers To Off Case Args
TWM
Debt cancellation is mandate
Cross apply 1ac stuff
^ proves we are pha
fiat Title Five is a mandate
Plan text makes it topical – plan earmarks – it is pha - comes down to who we define PHA
C-i –
Socio-economic stuff
Policy failure stuff bad
Socio-economic issues can’t be separated from policy
No case meets
Need reason why ours is special
No abuse
still have ground
CP
Perm – double solvency
Perm – US cancel debt and Japan give money
US doesn’t give money in plan anyways
U