Grapevine Neg

Round # 2

Vs Team: Damien

Judge: Jonathan Paul



Off Case Args:

T- It’s

T- Public Health

Counter plan: The USFG should provide <insert plan text>. Funding will tradeoff with Bush’s Emergency Program for AIDS relief to SSA. Enforcement Garanteed

Competition: Counterplan is text competitive/net benefits
Solvency – Pepfar is a sacred cow that required cuts to other PHA programs in order to be funded.

Aid Tradeoff-
Carpe has been successful in the past but proposed budget cuts put its programs at risk.

B. Link
Focusing resources on disease aid and humanitarian assistance trades-off with buiodiversity funding.

USAID budget cuts undermind Carpe effectiveness

C. Impact
Key to stability in the congo basin

Congo war laundry list of impacts.


2nr Strategy:

Counterplan, Carpe DA