Round 2
Vs Team: Cathedral Prep
Judge: Brian Peterson
Case Args:
various
Off Case Args:
AU do it
topicality
K
THE AFF’S CONSTRUCTION OF AFRICA AS THE PRETEXT TO A SOLUTION ONLY FURTHERS THE IDEA THAT AFRICA IS UNCIVILZED AND A MEANS BY WHICH THE WEST CAN ASSERT ITS SUBJECTIVITY, LIMITING DISCOURSE OF AFRICA FOR ITSELF.
MBEMBE 96 (achille, on the postcolony, p3)
“whether in everyday discourse…to this presupposition”
THE DISCOURSE OF EUROCENTRISM NATURALIZES OPPRESSION AND MAKES EXTINCTION INEVITABLE
LANDER 6 (“unbecoming modern: colonialism, modernity, colonial modernities”, p191-2
“the perspective of Eurocentric…tendencies of globalization”
VOTE NEG TO REJECT THE 1AC’S EUROCENTRIC REPRESENTATIONS
ASANTE 98 (molefi, the afrocentric idea, p41-2)
“afrocentricity thus becomes…and antiracist”
FOCUSING ON WHAT THE GOV SHOULD DO FURTHER FOSTERS THE PERCEIVED POWERLESSNESS OF OUR OWN LIVES. THIS FORM OF MENTAL DEPUTY POLITICS IS DETRIMENTAL. IT IS AT THE ROOT OF ALL VIOLENCE AND WE MUST ABANDON THIS TYPE OF THINKING IF WE ARE EVER TO MOVE BEYOND VIOLENCE.
KAPPELER 95 (the will to violence: the politics of personal behavior p 10-11)
“we are the war…values of war and violence”
THE IMPACT IS EXTINCTION – THE LACK OF OVERCOMING VIOLENCE GUARANTEES A WORLD A MILLION TIMES WORSE THAN NUCLEAR WAR
SETHI 89 (“gandhian critique of western peace movements”)
“the strategic doctrines…of nuclear weapons”
THE AFF PREOCCUPATION WITH THE MOVEMENT, SPREAD, AND PLACE OF DISEASE AMOUNTS TO A BORDER POLICING WHICH IS DESIGNED TO CONTROL THE MOVEMENT OF PEOPLES AND VIRUSES WITHIN A DISCURSIVE FRAME THAT CREATES A BORDER OF TERROR
FERNANDEZ 04 (sovereign lives)
“the bio-geographical provenance…the body’s boundaries”
Highland Park Neg Round #3
T- PHA Prevention, not treatment
Afrocentrism K
CP (PIC) – Health care, not public health (Net benefit of colonialism)
Vs Team: Cathedral Prep
Judge: Brian Peterson
Case Args:
various
Off Case Args:
AU do it
topicality
K
THE AFF’S CONSTRUCTION OF AFRICA AS THE PRETEXT TO A SOLUTION ONLY FURTHERS THE IDEA THAT AFRICA IS UNCIVILZED AND A MEANS BY WHICH THE WEST CAN ASSERT ITS SUBJECTIVITY, LIMITING DISCOURSE OF AFRICA FOR ITSELF.
MBEMBE 96 (achille, on the postcolony, p3)
“whether in everyday discourse…to this presupposition”
THE DISCOURSE OF EUROCENTRISM NATURALIZES OPPRESSION AND MAKES EXTINCTION INEVITABLE
LANDER 6 (“unbecoming modern: colonialism, modernity, colonial modernities”, p191-2
“the perspective of Eurocentric…tendencies of globalization”
VOTE NEG TO REJECT THE 1AC’S EUROCENTRIC REPRESENTATIONS
ASANTE 98 (molefi, the afrocentric idea, p41-2)
“afrocentricity thus becomes…and antiracist”
FOCUSING ON WHAT THE GOV SHOULD DO FURTHER FOSTERS THE PERCEIVED POWERLESSNESS OF OUR OWN LIVES. THIS FORM OF MENTAL DEPUTY POLITICS IS DETRIMENTAL. IT IS AT THE ROOT OF ALL VIOLENCE AND WE MUST ABANDON THIS TYPE OF THINKING IF WE ARE EVER TO MOVE BEYOND VIOLENCE.
KAPPELER 95 (the will to violence: the politics of personal behavior p 10-11)
“we are the war…values of war and violence”
THE IMPACT IS EXTINCTION – THE LACK OF OVERCOMING VIOLENCE GUARANTEES A WORLD A MILLION TIMES WORSE THAN NUCLEAR WAR
SETHI 89 (“gandhian critique of western peace movements”)
“the strategic doctrines…of nuclear weapons”
THE AFF PREOCCUPATION WITH THE MOVEMENT, SPREAD, AND PLACE OF DISEASE AMOUNTS TO A BORDER POLICING WHICH IS DESIGNED TO CONTROL THE MOVEMENT OF PEOPLES AND VIRUSES WITHIN A DISCURSIVE FRAME THAT CREATES A BORDER OF TERROR
FERNANDEZ 04 (sovereign lives)
“the bio-geographical provenance…the body’s boundaries”
Highland Park Neg Round #3
T- PHA Prevention, not treatment
Afrocentrism K
CP (PIC) – Health care, not public health (Net benefit of colonialism)